There is a sensible order to learning pastes, and starting with the wrong one is a good way to conclude that making your own is not worth it.
Why Thai red first?
Because it uses dried chillies rather than fresh, which are cheap and always available. It has a manageable ingredient list. And the quantity used is small, so a batch covers several curries.
Most importantly it teaches the frying stage, splitting coconut cream and cooking the paste in the released oil, which is the technique everything else depends on.
Why not green?
It needs a large quantity of fresh green chillies, fresh coriander root and often holy basil, none of which is reliably stocked outside a South East Asian grocer. It is also less forgiving, since fresh herbs vary more than dried chillies.
It is an excellent paste and a poor first one.
What comes second?
An Indonesian bumbu dasar, which introduces the long fry until the oil separates. It takes twenty minutes of stirring and demonstrates the difference between an under-fried and a properly fried paste more clearly than anything else.
What comes third?
A Malaysian rempah, which is the most demanding of the common pastes. It has the longest ingredient list, the largest quantity and the longest frying time. Attempting it first is where people give up.
Where do Indian pastes fit?
Separately, since they work differently. A vindaloo or tandoori paste is a marinade rather than a sauce base, and it is easier than any South East Asian paste, since it is essentially blending soft ingredients with vinegar or yoghurt.
Either is a reasonable first paste if Indian cooking is your interest.
What should you learn alongside?
- Toasting shrimp paste in foil, which most pastes need.
- Slicing lemongrass thinly before blending.
- Recognising when a paste has fried far enough.
- Freezing in ice cube trays.
How many should you keep?
Two is plenty for most kitchens. A Thai red and a bumbu dasar between them cover a wide range, and both freeze for three months. Adding more before you use those regularly tends to fill a freezer rather than a menu.
How long does the first one take?
Around forty minutes including shopping list confusion, and half that the second time. The first attempt at any paste is slower than the recipe suggests because you are identifying unfamiliar ingredients as much as preparing them.
What is the most common beginner error?
Not frying it long enough, by a wide margin. The second is being cautious with quantities, which gives a thin curry. Both are easy to correct once you know to expect them, and both explain most disappointing first attempts.
Should you make a large batch first time?
A standard batch rather than a small one. Halving a paste recipe makes the blending harder and the pounding no faster, and you learn as much from a full batch. Anything you do not use freezes for three months.
What if you dislike the result?
Check the frying before concluding the recipe was wrong, since an under-fried paste accounts for most disappointing first attempts. If the paste was fried until the oil separated and it still tastes wrong, the balance is worth adjusting rather than the technique.
Is it worth learning at all?
If you cook South East Asian food more than occasionally, yes, since the difference between a fresh paste and a jar is real. If you cook it twice a year, a good bought paste fried properly is a perfectly respectable answer.
What order should you learn them in?
Thai red, then an Indonesian bumbu, then a Malaysian rempah, with Indian marinade pastes fitting in anywhere. That sequence moves from shortest to longest frying time, which is the skill each one is really teaching.
Do you need to learn any at all?
Not for Indian or Pakistani cooking, which builds its base in the pan from onion, ginger and garlic rather than from a paste. Pastes matter for Thai, Malaysian and Indonesian food specifically, so what you cook decides whether this is worth your time.