A watery curry is almost always a curry with too much liquid in it, not one short of a thickener. The fix that works best is also the cheapest: take the lid off and let it reduce. Everything else on this page is for when you are short of time.
Where is the extra water coming from?
More places than most people count. Chicken releases a surprising amount of moisture as it cooks, particularly if it went into the pan straight from the fridge or was previously frozen. Onions that were not browned long enough are still holding much of their original water. Tinned tomatoes carry a great deal of liquid. Vegetables such as courgette and mushroom release almost their entire volume.
On top of that, most recipes add stock or water as insurance against catching, and a lid keeps every bit of it in the pan.
How do you reduce a sauce properly?
Take the lid off, raise the heat to a steady simmer, and stir every couple of minutes so the base does not catch. Ten to fifteen minutes will visibly transform most sauces. A wide pan reduces far faster than a tall narrow one, because evaporation depends on surface area.
The advantage over any thickener is that reduction concentrates flavour rather than diluting it. A cornflour slurry makes a thin sauce thicker and no more interesting. Reduction makes it thicker and better.
If the chicken is already cooked through and you are worried about it toughening, lift the pieces out with a slotted spoon, reduce the sauce hard, then return them for the last two minutes.
What can you add to thicken it?
- Ground almonds or cashew paste - two tablespoons thicken and enrich, and it is what a korma uses. Add and simmer for five minutes.
- Gram flour - a teaspoon, toasted dry in a separate pan first to remove the raw taste, then whisked in.
- Cornflour slurry - a teaspoon in two tablespoons of cold water. Effective and quick, but it gives a slightly glossy takeaway texture some people dislike.
- Coconut cream - the solid part from the top of a chilled tin, which thickens as it reduces.
- A boiled potato, mashed - crude but genuinely useful in a Massaman-style or Caribbean curry.
What should you avoid?
Plain flour stirred straight into the sauce, which goes lumpy and tastes raw. Excessive tomato puree, which makes the sauce thicker and also sharper and slightly metallic. And boiling it hard for a long time with the chicken still in, which reduces the sauce and ruins the meat at the same time.
How do you stop it happening next time?
- Brown the onions properly, so their water leaves at the start rather than the end.
- Cook the tomato stage until oil visibly separates before adding anything else.
- Pat the chicken dry before it goes in, and never add frozen chicken directly to a sauce.
- Add less liquid than the recipe suggests. You can always add more, and you cannot easily take it out.
- Simmer with the lid off or partly off for most of the cooking time.
- Cook watery vegetables separately and stir them in near the end.
How thick should it actually be?
Thick enough to coat the back of a spoon and to sit on rice without immediately running across the plate. A dragged spoon should leave a channel across the base of the pan that closes slowly rather than instantly. Different dishes vary considerably, and a bhuna or jalfrezi should be nearly dry, while a korma is properly pourable.
Does the pan change how fast it reduces?
Substantially, and it is the variable most people never consider. Evaporation happens at the surface, so a wide shallow pan reduces a sauce perhaps twice as fast as a tall narrow one holding the same volume. If a curry is stubbornly refusing to thicken, tipping it into a frying pan for ten minutes often does more than any amount of extra simmering in a deep saucepan.
Should you reduce before or after adding cream?
Before, always. Cream, coconut milk and yoghurt are all emulsions that break when boiled hard, and a sauce reduced after they go in tends to turn grainy or oily. Get the consistency right first, then stir the dairy in over a low heat at the very end and take it no further than a bare simmer.