The working answers are twenty to twenty-five minutes for boneless thigh, eight to twelve for breast, and thirty-five to forty-five for bone-in pieces. Those are simmering times at a gentle bubble, counted from the moment the sauce comes back up to heat after the chicken goes in.
Why do the cuts differ so much?
Because they are made of different proportions of the same materials. Thigh has plenty of collagen, which needs sustained time above about 70C to soften into gelatine, and until that happens the meat is still slightly chewy. Twelve minutes gives you cooked but not tender thigh. Twenty-five gives you tender.
Breast has almost no collagen to convert, so there is no reward for waiting. It reaches its best texture the moment it is safely cooked and declines from there.
Bone-in pieces sit somewhere else again. The bone slows heat transfer, so the meat nearest it takes far longer, and the surrounding connective tissue benefits from the extra time.
What if the sauce needs longer than the chicken?
This is the tension in every curry, and the answer is to stop treating them as one process. Build the sauce to nearly finished before the chicken arrives, so the meat is only ever in the pan for its own cooking time.
If the sauce still needs reducing at the end, lift the chicken out with a slotted spoon, boil the sauce down hard for five to ten minutes, then return the meat for the final two. Nothing is lost and the meat is spared.
How do you know it is cooked?
A probe thermometer into the thickest part is the only reliable method. Look for 74C, held for a moment. Without one, cut the largest piece in half: the juices should run clear rather than pink, and there should be no translucent or glassy appearance in the middle.
Bone-in pieces need checking right against the bone, which is the last part to come up to temperature. A slight pinkness in the meat immediately touching the bone can be harmless in a properly cooked bird, but if you are uncertain, give it another five minutes.
Can chicken be overcooked in a sauce?
Breast, easily and quickly. Thigh, much less so, and an hour of gentle simmering will produce something that falls apart pleasantly rather than something ruined. What does damage thigh is a rolling boil, which agitates the pieces until they shred and squeezes moisture out faster than the collagen can compensate for.
Keep the surface at a lazy bubble rather than a churn. If the pan is spitting, it is too hot.
Does the size of the pieces change things?
Substantially, and it is the variable people forget. Three centimetre chunks of thigh cook in around twenty minutes. Whole thighs left uncut need closer to thirty-five. Small two centimetre pieces are done in twelve but dry out sooner afterwards.
Cut everything to a consistent size, whatever size you choose. A pan holding pieces ranging from small to large will always contain some that are dry by the time the largest are ready.
What about marinated chicken?
Yoghurt-marinated chicken cooks slightly faster, because the acid has already begun to loosen the proteins. Reduce the times above by around a fifth and check earlier than you think you need to. Chicken that has been charred under a grill first, as it is for tikka masala, needs only five to eight minutes in the sauce, since it arrives nearly cooked and is there to absorb flavour rather than to finish.
Does letting it stand off the heat help?
Yes, and it is free. Five to ten minutes with the lid on and the burner off lets the temperature even out through the larger pieces and gives the muscle fibres a chance to relax and reabsorb some of the juice they squeezed out. Chicken carved or served straight from a bubbling pan loses noticeably more liquid onto the plate.
Does the chicken keep cooking in the sauce afterwards?
For a while. A full pan holds a great deal of heat and will sit above 70C for fifteen minutes or more after the hob goes off, which is long enough to take breast meat past its best. If you are cooking ahead and plan to reheat, pull the chicken a couple of minutes early and let the reheating finish the job rather than cooking it twice.