A madras should be hot enough that you register it on every mouthful and mild enough that you can still taste the coriander, the tamarind and the onion underneath. In practical terms that is around three teaspoons of Kashmiri chilli plus one to one and a half of a hotter powder, for four portions.
Why is the quantity split across two chillies?
Because they do different jobs. Kashmiri chilli powder is roughly 1,500 to 2,000 on the Scoville scale, which is mild, but it is intensely coloured and carries a fruity, slightly smoky flavour. You can use three teaspoons of it without the dish becoming punishing.
Standard hot chilli powder runs anywhere from 30,000 to 50,000 Scoville units and supplies the actual burn in a much smaller quantity. Using only the hot one gives you a curry that is fierce and pale. Using only the Kashmiri gives you a curry that looks right and does nothing.
How does that compare to other dishes?
- Korma - none, or a pinch of Kashmiri for colour.
- Tikka masala - around two teaspoons of Kashmiri, no hot chilli.
- Bhuna - two teaspoons of Kashmiri and perhaps half a teaspoon of hot.
- Madras - three of Kashmiri and one to one and a half of hot.
- Vindaloo - three of Kashmiri and two to three of hot, plus whole dried chillies.
Does the heat change during cooking?
It does, and in both directions. Capsaicin is fat-soluble, so frying chilli in oil distributes it evenly through the dish and makes the heat feel more integrated and slightly stronger. A long simmer then mellows the sharp edge of it without reducing the total quantity.
More noticeably, a curry left overnight tastes hotter the next day, because the capsaicin continues to distribute through the fat in the sauce. If you are cooking ahead, aim slightly below your target.
How do you calibrate to your own tolerance?
Change one variable at a time and write it down. Cook the recipe at one teaspoon of hot chilli, note whether it was too much or too little, and adjust by half a teaspoon next time. Two or three attempts will land you on your own number, which is more useful than any recipe.
Tolerance also builds. People who eat chilli regularly experience less burn from the same quantity, because the receptors involved become less responsive over time. A level that felt severe a year ago may feel moderate now.
Does the chilli brand matter?
Considerably, and it is the reason recipes cannot be precise. Chilli powder is a ground blend of whatever varieties the producer used, and the heat varies enormously between brands and between batches from the same brand. Two teaspoons from one jar may equal one from another.
The only reliable approach is to learn your own jar. Taste a tiny pinch on the tongue before you start using a new one, and adjust the quantity accordingly.
Should the heat be immediate or building?
A good madras builds. The first mouthful should be flavourful with the heat arriving a second later, and it should accumulate gently over the plate rather than hitting hard at the front. Front-loaded heat usually means raw chilli added late, and building heat usually means chilli fried properly into the fat at the right stage.
Does the meat affect how hot it seems?
Noticeably. Fat binds capsaicin, so a lamb madras made with shoulder tastes less fierce than a chicken breast version at identical chilli levels, because the fat distributes and buffers the heat. A prawn or vegetable madras, with very little fat in it, will taste hotter than the same recipe made with lamb.
Adjust accordingly rather than following one number across every version.
What about heat in the mouth versus afterwards?
Different chillies behave differently here, and it is worth knowing before you cook for other people. Standard chilli powder gives a burn that peaks quickly and fades. Very hot varieties such as naga or scotch bonnet build slowly and last far longer, sometimes for twenty minutes after the plate is cleared. A madras built on the first is manageable, and one built on the second can catch guests out badly.