Back to Thai

What Does Tamarind Do in a Massaman?

What Does Tamarind Do in a Massaman?
Curry Recipes Team 19 April 2026

Tamarind is the ingredient that makes massaman work. The dish contains palm sugar, coconut cream, sweet onion and potato, and without something sharp pushing back against all four it tastes flat and sickly rather than rich.

What does tamarind taste like?

Sour first, with a dark fruity depth behind it and a slight molasses quality. It is closer to dried dates gone sour than to lemon, and that body is what distinguishes it from a simple acid.

That depth matters here. Lime juice is sharp and clean and disappears quickly, where tamarind sits underneath the whole dish and gives it a foundation.

How much should you use?

Two tablespoons of concentrate for four to six portions, which is more than most recipes suggest. A massaman should taste distinctly sweet-and-sour rather than merely sweet, and the tamarind needs to be assertive enough to register.

Strength varies enormously between brands, so taste before committing. Some concentrates are three times as sour as others.

When does it go in?

In the last twenty minutes rather than at the start. Added early it cooks down and loses definition over ninety minutes of braising. Added right at the end it tastes separate and slightly raw.

There is also a practical reason to keep it late. Acid slows the softening of potatoes considerably, so tamarind added before the potatoes are tender can leave them stubbornly firm.

Which form should you buy?

  • Concentrate in a jar - dark, strong and convenient. Two tablespoons for four portions.
  • Compressed block - the best flavour and the most work. Soak 50g in 150ml hot water for twenty minutes, squeeze with your fingers and strain out the fibres and seeds.
  • Ready-made pulp in a tub - a reasonable middle ground, already strained.

What can you substitute?

Lime juice is the usual fallback, at the juice of one to one and a half limes in place of two tablespoons of tamarind. It is sharper and thinner and lacks the fruity body, so the curry will taste less rounded.

Amchoor, made from dried green mango, gives a fruity sourness closer to tamarind. A tablespoon of rice vinegar with a teaspoon of brown sugar approximates it roughly. Pomegranate molasses is unorthodox and works surprisingly well.

Can you use too much?

Easily, and an over-tamarinded curry tastes puckering and faintly metallic. If it has gone too far, a little extra palm sugar rounds it off, and more salt from fish sauce helps because salt suppresses the perception of sourness.

How do you know when the balance is right?

Taste for all three at once. You should be able to identify sweetness, saltiness and sourness as distinct sensations, none of them dominating. If you can only taste sweetness, add tamarind and fish sauce. If it tastes harsh, add sugar.

Adjust one element at a time and taste between each, since changing two at once makes it impossible to know what worked.

How do you prepare a block?

Break off a walnut-sized piece, cover with 150ml of hot water and leave twenty minutes. Work it with your fingers until the pulp separates from the fibres and seeds, then push the whole lot through a sieve, scraping the underside. What comes through is what you use.

Does it keep?

Jarred concentrate lasts six months or more in the fridge and is very stable. Blocks keep almost indefinitely in a cupboard, hardening with age without any effect once soaked. Home-made pulp keeps a week refrigerated and freezes well in an ice cube tray.

Is tamarind used elsewhere in Thai cooking?

Widely, and recognising it explains several dishes. Pad Thai depends on it for the sour note in the sauce, as do many southern Thai curries and the sweet-and-sour tamarind fish dishes. Once you know the flavour, you start identifying it on restaurant menus you had not connected before.

Does it thicken the sauce?

Slightly, and it is a minor secondary benefit rather than a reason to use it. Tamarind pulp carries fibre and pectin that give a little body, which is one reason a block-prepared pulp behaves marginally differently from a thin concentrate. The thickening in a massaman comes mostly from the peanuts and the potato.