Almost every Jamaican curry recipe begins by heating oil and frying dry curry powder in it before anything else goes in the pot. The technique is called burning the curry, and it is what separates a Jamaican curry from one made by stirring powder into a sauce.
What actually happens?
The dry spices meet hot oil and their fat-soluble aromatic compounds are released and dispersed. At the same time the powder toasts, which develops new roasted flavours and drives off the dusty rawness of uncooked spice.
The oil takes on the colour, turning deep gold or orange, and that coloured oil then carries the flavour through the entire dish.
How is it different from blooming spices?
It is the same principle taken further. Indian cooking blooms whole or ground spices in fat over a moderate heat for thirty seconds to a minute. Jamaican burning uses a hotter pan and two or three minutes, and the powder visibly darkens.
The result is more toasted and less bright, which suits the long slow braises the technique belongs to.
Does it actually burn?
It should not, and the name overstates it. What you want is dark, foaming and intensely aromatic, stopping just before anything scorches. Genuine burning produces an acrid bitterness that ruins the pot.
The margin is narrower than most techniques allow, which is why it needs constant stirring and full attention for the two or three minutes it takes.
How do you know when it is right?
- The colour deepens - from bright yellow to a darker gold or brown.
- It foams - bubbling actively in the oil.
- The oil colours - taking on the yellow of the turmeric.
- The smell changes - from raw and dusty to distinctly toasted.
- It thickens slightly - forming a loose paste rather than sitting as loose powder.
What if it goes too far?
Black specks or an acrid smell mean it has scorched, and there is no recovering it. Tip it out, wipe the pan and start again with fresh oil and powder. Two minutes wasted is considerably better than a ruined braise.
Turmeric in particular turns bitter quickly, and Jamaican curry powder is turmeric-heavy.
How much oil?
Generous, around four tablespoons for a curry serving six. The powder needs enough fat to move in freely, and a dry pan with a scattering of oil scorches almost immediately.
That oil stays in the dish, so it is not wasted, and Caribbean curries are richer than Indian ones partly for this reason.
Does it work with other curry powders?
The technique transfers, and the result differs. A Jamaican powder is built for it, being turmeric-heavy with allspice. An Indian Madras powder burned the same way tastes good and noticeably different, since it carries more chilli and cumin.
Whichever you use, watch it closely, since blends heavy in ground chilli scorch faster than turmeric-based ones.
Does the oil temperature matter?
It should be shimmering but not smoking, around 180C. Too cool and the powder soaks up oil without toasting, going heavy and greasy. Too hot and it scorches within seconds. Medium-high on most hobs is right, and a heavy pan gives you more control than a thin one.
What goes in immediately afterwards?
The meat, usually, which stops the powder cooking further and starts coating it in the flavoured oil. Some cooks add onions first. Either way something has to go in within thirty seconds of the powder reaching the right stage, since it will not simply hold there.
Should all the powder be burned?
No, and the standard approach splits it. Half goes into the marinade where it penetrates the meat over several hours, and half is burned in the oil. Burning all of it means no marinade, and marinating all of it means losing the toasted depth entirely.
Does it work in a pressure cooker?
The burning has to happen on the saute setting before the lid goes on, since no pressure cooker reaches the temperature once sealed. That is straightforward and it is the reason a pressure cooker suits Caribbean curry better than a slow cooker, which cannot brown or burn anything at all.